Exemptions & Certificates Kentucky November 2, 2026 · 3 min read

Kentucky Court of Appeals: Bullion Buyers Must Get Sales Tax Refunds Through the Retailer (Huston v. Kentucky)

On October 30, 2026, the Kentucky Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal of lawsuits seeking refunds of sales tax paid on gold and silver bullion. The case is Huston v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, No. 2025-CA-1034-MR.

The court held that individual buyers can't get a refund directly from the Department of Revenue (DOR). The retailer that collected the tax has to request the refund and pass it back to customers.

Retailer Money Metals lost because it went to court without first filing a refund claim with DOR.

The Ruling at a Glance

PartyArgumentResult
Individual buyers (Huston, Strayer, Earl)Could sue directly under KRS 139.4802 because a DOR refund claim would be futileRejected. Under KRS 139.770 and KRS 134.580, only the retailer that remitted the tax is the taxpayer who can seek a refund
Money Metals (retailer)Could sue for refunds for itself and its customersRejected. It skipped the DOR refund process, so the trial court had no jurisdiction
All claimsDismissal affirmed. Other issues moot

Do you already owe tax in Kentucky?

Two questions. No email required to see your answer.

Have your sales into Kentucky grown over the last four quarters?

Question 1 of 2

Background: The Bullion Exemption

In 2024, House Bill 8 amended KRS 139.480 to exempt sales of currency and bullion made after August 1, 2024. Governor Beshear issued a line-item veto. The House treated it as invalid, relying on an Attorney General opinion.

DOR kept collecting tax on bullion at the Governor's direction. In 2025, lawmakers passed House Bill 2, codified at KRS 139.4802. It lets anyone who paid the tax on exempt bullion after August 1, 2024 bring an action for a refund. The legislature overrode the Governor's veto on March 27, 2025.

The exemption is now at KRS 139.480(36). It covers gold, silver, platinum and palladium bars, ingots and coins valued by metal content, but not jewelry.

Why the Buyers Lost

The court read KRS 139.770(3) and KRS 134.580(2) together. Refunds go to "the person who paid the tax" into the State Treasury, and that's the retailer.

KRS 139.4802 doesn't override that process. Even if buyers stood in the same place as retailers, they would still have to exhaust the DOR refund process first.

The court's answer for buyers: ask your retailer (here, Coins+) to request the refund and pass it back.

Why Money Metals Lost

Money Metals sent DOR more than $55,000 in Kentucky tax collected from more than 800 customers. It didn't claim the DOR process was inadequate or the statute unconstitutional.

Following Popplewell's Alligator Dock and Commonwealth v. DLX, the court held that failing to exhaust administrative remedies left the trial court without jurisdiction.

What Bullion Dealers Should Do

If you collected Kentucky tax on exempt bullion or currency after August 1, 2024, file a refund claim with DOR under KRS 139.770. Then return the money to your customers, because a retailer can't keep a refund of tax it collected from buyers.

Make sure your system doesn't charge tax on qualifying bullion. For more exemption news, see our Sales Tax Updates page.

FAQ

Can I get a Kentucky sales tax refund on bullion directly from the state?

No. Under Huston v. Kentucky, individual buyers have to get the refund through the retailer that collected the tax. The retailer files with DOR and returns the money.

Why did Money Metals lose its case?

It sued without first filing a refund claim with the Kentucky Department of Revenue. The court said it had to exhaust that remedy first.

Is gold and silver bullion exempt from Kentucky sales tax?

Yes. Qualifying currency and bullion are exempt under KRS 139.480. The exemption doesn't cover medallions or coins made into jewelry.

What time period do the refunds cover?

KRS 139.4802 covers tax paid on exempt currency or bullion on or after August 1, 2024.

Book a free consultation with our team at sales.tax.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not tax or legal advice. The decision may be subject to further review.

What this means for your business

If your sales into Kentucky have grown with prices, you may have crossed the economic nexus threshold without changing anything about how you sell. We’ll tell you where you stand in 30 minutes — and if there’s nothing to fix, we’ll say so.

Real accountants, not software No obligation Get on a call today, not in a ticket queue