Registrations & VDAs Florida October 28, 2026 · 5 min read

Florida Judge Strikes Down DOR Sales Tax Rule Requiring "Game of Skill" Attestations for Amusement Machines

A Florida administrative law judge struck down the Department of Revenue's new coin-operated amusement machine registration attestations on October 27, 2026. In Amusement Machine Owners' Association of Florida v. Florida Department of Revenue (DOAH Case No. 26-4757RX), Administrative Law Judge Justin M. Keen ruled that the agency overstepped its authority when it revised Rule 12A-1.097(8)(a)–(d), F.A.C.

The invalidated rule revision, which had taken effect September 3, 2026, forced businesses applying for or renewing an annual Amusement Machine Certificate (Form DR-18) to swear under penalties of perjury that every registered machine is "only a game of skill" and not a gambling device.

Judge Keen held that the Florida Department of Revenue (DOR) is authorized to collect the state's 4% sales tax on amusement machine receipts—not to rewrite the statutory definition of a coin-operated amusement machine or police Florida's gambling laws.

What DOR Added to the DR-18 Forms in September 2026

To operate coin-operated amusement machines in Florida, operators must register each location and pay an annual $30 per-machine certificate fee using four forms incorporated into Rule 12A-1.097(8): Form DR-18 (*Application for Amusement Machine Certificate*), Form DR-18N (*General Information and Instructions*), Form DR-18R (*Renewal Application*) and Form DR-18RS (*Second Notice*).

Effective September 3, 2026, DOR revised the sworn signature block on those forms to require operators to certify under penalties of perjury (a third-degree felony under Section 92.525, Florida Statutes) that each machine is "only a game of skill" and is not:

A machine using mechanical slot reels, video depictions of slot reels or symbols, or video simulations of casino, banked card, poker, bingo, pull-tab, lotto, roulette or craps games.

A game in which the player does not control the outcome through skill or where the outcome depends on factors not visible, known or predictable to the player.

A video poker game or any machine construed as a gambling device under Florida law or 15 U.S.C. § 1171.

During the July 2026 public comment period, the Amusement Machine Owners' Association of Florida warned that the new oath created a felony trap—even for operators of jukeboxes, music machines, telescopes and mechanical rides, which are listed right on Form DR-18 as taxable amusement machines despite not being "games of skill."

Do you already owe tax in Florida?

Two questions. No email required to see your answer.

Have your sales into Florida grown over the last four quarters?

Question 1 of 2

Why the Judge Invalidated the Rule Revision

In his 24-page Summary Final Order on October 27, 2026, Judge Keen invalidated the revision to Rule 12A-1.097(8)(a)–(d) on two independent grounds under Florida's Administrative Procedure Act (Section 120.52(8)(b) and (c), F.S.):

1. DOR exceeded its grant of rulemaking authority (§ 120.52(8)(b)). The tax statutes DOR cited—Sections 212.05(1)(h)6., 212.12(1)(b)2., 212.18(2), 212.18(3)(a) and 213.06(1), F.S.—authorize the agency to administer tax rates, collect revenue and register dealers. Judge Keen wrote that "redefining which machines are lawful in accord with the state gambling statutes does not administer a tax," and none of those statutes empowers DOR to enforce laws administered by other agencies.

2. The rule enlarged and modified the sales tax statute (§ 120.52(8)(c)). Florida's sales tax law already defines "coin-operated amusement machine" broadly in Section 212.02(24), F.S. to include pinball machines, music machines, jukeboxes, mechanical games, video games, arcade games, billiard tables, moving picture viewers, shooting galleries and similar devices. By importing narrower "game of skill" and slot-machine language from the Family Amusement Games Act (§ 546.10, F.S.) and gambling laws (§ 849.16, F.S.), DOR impermissibly modified the tax statute. As Judge Keen noted, the Florida Supreme Court has even held that proceeds from gambling equipment are still subject to Chapter 212 sales and use tax.

Invalidated Rule vs. Ongoing Florida Tax Rules

RequirementStatus After Oct. 27, 2026 DOAH OrderStatutory / Rule Basis
Sworn "game of skill" and non-gambling attestation on Forms DR-18, DR-18N, DR-18R and DR-18RSStruck down as invalid (agency has 30 days to appeal)DOAH Case No. 26-4757RX invalidating Sept. 3, 2026 revision to Rule 12A-1.097(8)(a)-(d)
Sales & use tax registration (Form DR-11) for each county where machines operateRemains required§ 212.05(1)(h)3. & § 212.18(3), F.S.
Annual Amusement Machine Certificate (Form DR-18C) and $30 per-machine feeRemains required (valid July 1 through June 30; renew by June 30)§ 212.05(1)(h)3.a., F.S.
Sales tax rate on amusement machine gross receipts4% state sales tax plus applicable county discretionary sales surtax (calculated using statutory divisor)§ 212.05(1)(h)1., F.S.

What Florida Operators Should Know

The DOAH ruling wipes out the September 3, 2026 attestation revision, though DOR has 30 days under Section 120.68, F.S. to appeal the final order to the First District Court of Appeal.

All core Florida sales tax registration and tax remittance rules remain unchanged: operators must still hold an active sales and use tax Certificate of Registration (Form DR-11) in every county where they place machines, pay the $30 per-machine annual certificate fee, display the DR-18C certificate at each location, and remit the 4% state sales tax (plus local surtax) on machine receipts.

For multi-state operators also tracking registration rules and out-of-state thresholds, see our economic nexus guide and our Sales Tax Updates page.

FAQ

What did the Florida judge decide in the amusement machine sales tax rule case?

On October 27, 2026, Administrative Law Judge Justin M. Keen issued a Summary Final Order in DOAH Case No. 26-4757RX invalidating the Florida Department of Revenue's September 3, 2026 revision to Rule 12A-1.097(8)(a)–(d), which had added a sworn "game of skill" attestation to Forms DR-18, DR-18N, DR-18R and DR-18RS.

Why did the judge strike down the Florida DOR's DR-18 form changes?

The judge ruled that the Department of Revenue exceeded its rulemaking authority under Section 120.52(8)(b), Florida Statutes, and impermissibly modified Section 212.02(24) under Section 120.52(8)(c) by importing "game of skill" and gambling definitions from Chapters 546 and 849 into sales tax registration forms.

What is the sales tax rate on coin-operated amusement machines in Florida?

Under Section 212.05(1)(h), Florida Statutes, charges for the use of coin-operated amusement machines are taxed at a 4% state sales tax rate, plus any applicable county discretionary sales surtax, calculated using the statutory divisor for the machine's location.

Do Florida businesses still need an annual Amusement Machine Certificate?

Yes. Operators must still hold a sales tax registration for each county where machines are located, pay the $30 annual fee per machine, and obtain and display an Amusement Machine Certificate (Form DR-18C), which runs from July 1 through June 30 each year.

Book a free consultation with our team at sales.tax.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not tax or legal advice. The October 27, 2026 Summary Final Order in DOAH Case No. 26-4757RX is subject to a 30-day appellate review window under Section 120.68, Florida Statutes.

What this means for your business

If your sales into Florida have grown with prices, you may have crossed the economic nexus threshold without changing anything about how you sell. We’ll tell you where you stand in 30 minutes — and if there’s nothing to fix, we’ll say so.

Real accountants, not software No obligation Get on a call today, not in a ticket queue